jueves, 25 de febrero de 2010

Sobre verdad y ficción, J. J. Saer

"El rechazo escrupuloso de todo elemento ficticio no es un criterio de verdad. Puesto que el concepto mismo de verdad es incierto y su definición integra elementos dispares y aun contradictorios, es la verdad como objetivo unívoco del texto y no solamente la presencia de elementos ficticios lo que merece, cuando se trata del género biográfico o autobiográfico, una discusión minuciosa. Lo mismo podemos decir del género, tan de moda en la actualidad, llamado, con certidumbre excesiva, non-fiction: su especificidad se basa en la exclusión de todo rastro ficticio, pero esa exclusión no es de por sí garantía de veracidad. Aun cuando la intención de veracidad sea sincera y los hechos narrados rigurosamente exactos sólo que no siempre es así sigue existiendo el obstáculo de la autenticidad de las fuentes, de los criterios interpretativos y de las turbulencias de sentido propios a toda construcción verbal. Estas dificultades, familiares en lógica y ampliamente debatidas en el campo de las ciencias humanas, no parecen preocupar a los practicantes felices de la non-fiction. Las ventajas innegables de una vida mundana como la de Truman Capote no deben hacernos olvidar que una proposición, por no ser ficticia, no es automáticamente verdadera.

Podemos por lo tanto afirmar que la verdad no es necesariamente lo contrario de la ficción, y que cuando optamos por la práctica de la ficción no lo hacemos con el propósito turbio de tergiversar la verdad. En cuanto a la dependencia jerárquica entre verdad y ficción, según la cual la primera poseería una positividad mayor que la segunda, es desde luego, en el plano que nos interesa, una mera fantasía moral. Aun con la mejor buena voluntad, aceptando esa jerarquía y atribuyendo a la verdad el campo de la realidad objetiva y a la ficción la dudosa expresión de lo subjetivo, persistirá siempre el problema principal, es decir la indeterminación de que sufren no la ficción subjetiva, relegada al terreno de lo inútil y caprichoso, sino la supuesta verdad objetiva y los géneros que pretenden representarla. Puesto que autobiografía, biografía, y todo lo que puede entrar en la categoría de non-fiction, la multitud de géneros que vuelven la espalda a la ficción, han decidido representar la supuesta verdad objetiva, son ellos quienes deben suministrar las pruebas de su eficacia. Esta obligación no es fácil de cumplir: todo lo que es verificable en este tipo de relatos es en general anecdótico y secundario, pero la credibilidad del relato y su razón de ser peligran si el autor abandona el plano de lo verificable."

20 comentarios:

  1. Belief in a higher power is just winning in less fortunate countries. The more instructed countries show agnosticism is on the ascent since web access and innovation assume a more noteworthy job. write my essay. Patterns demonstrate that on the off chance that you need to live in a retrogressive society with poor framework and abnormal amounts of absence of education, illness, defilement, and wrongdoing, at that point belief in higher powers is the best approach.

    ResponderEliminar
  2. Thank you for such an informative piece of work. It, indeed, is pretty informative! However, this is to inform the reader about online assignment expert, an Online assignment help providing company. The brand has about 5000 academic writers. I am one of those assignment help providing experts. When you do have a look at our website, the academic experts online would commence processing your assignment requirement with the top quality assignment writing services. For the students, looking for an assignment Expert Australia bound company, Online Assignment Expert has been the primary choice when it comes to Assignment Experts in Australia and abroad. Also deployed on the website are Free samples so that you can clear all your doubts on how to go about a particular assignment question and score HD by contacting our assignment experts. With an in-depth research going into each and every assignment we provide, the quality of our assignment help online has set industry breaking standards. In order to contact us in the most convenient way possible, we have accommodated a quick form and email to make our online assignment help Australia bound services in a jiffy.

    ResponderEliminar
  3. The purpose of writing this blog is exactly justifies the way you think and I am quite impressed with it. There are many services that provides IT assignment help to students. However, My Assignment Services stands behind the name of providing exceptional assignment writer who drafts supreme quality assignments for you. The assignments go through a rigorous in-depth quality check before it is handed to the students. You can learn a range of concepts such as SQL assignment help, Java, Database, Computer networks, Design algorithms, etc. Their experts are available 24x7 to provide constant support by the means of their IT assignment help and regularly enhance the knowledge needed for an exceptional career ahead.

    ResponderEliminar
  4. We offer a wide range of Pre Written Research Paper that seeks to provide a solution to all our clientele writing needs. Our writers have up doctorates credentials to give that assurance to our clientele of receiving high caliber Essay Writing Help Service to realize their aspirations of admirable grades affordably.

    ResponderEliminar
  5. Nice blog. Assignment Help service in Australia offering top-notch and original Assignment Help with quality results at an amazing price.
    Java homework help

    ResponderEliminar
  6. I love what you guys tend to be up too. This type of clever work and reporting!
    Keep up the amazing works guys I’ve included you guys to our blogroll.

    gmail login

    ResponderEliminar
  7. Thank you for sharing such a useful post with us, it will useful for everybody, so keep it up that is decent work. For more, Information Click Here.

    ResponderEliminar
  8. Get your sql assignment help and homework help today. MyAssignmentHelp.Net is the best assignment help service provider offered online by a team of experts tutors of Australia. Avail the offers of the best online assignment help service for SQL homework now.

    ResponderEliminar
  9. Get your mysql assignment help .MyAssignmentHelp.Net is the best assignment help service provider offered online by a team of experts tutors of Australia. our academic help experts and academic assignment writers are available online for you 24x7 to help you score the best marks in your class and secure the top grade in every assignment and provide 100% guaranteed best academic solutions to our students.Avail the offers of the best online assignment help service for MySQL homework now. Call or visit the website for further information.

    ResponderEliminar
  10. My Assignment Help provides professional Assignment Help and Assignment Help in various subjects. If you want your assignment to be done with good grades around 95%-100% then you have landed to the right place as we have efficient experts in Australia, USA and UK, New Zealand and Canada who offer help in all types of assignments. And assignment help has the potential capability of bringing out new facts and information? about the study along with the implementation of Assignment. As a trusted brand among students, we strive to provide 100% unique solutions at an affordable price. We deliver quality solutions for assignments in over 100 subjects plagiarism free answers. Our tutors focus on providing step-by-step solution to every assignment problem.

    ResponderEliminar
  11. It provides the selection committee insight about the prospective candidate's personality, intellect, and aptitude. Best Assignment Writing Service

    ResponderEliminar
  12. Thanks for sharing this great information an connect with MyAssignmentHelp for get the best engineering assignment help from an professional expert's

    ResponderEliminar
  13. Are you coming across Quicken error CC-501? If yes, then you can navigate to the Quickens site and search for the solution there. If by chance, you do not catch the solution then you should get in touch with our technical experts. You simply have to convey the error you are facing and ask them for the solution. They are well-versed in this field and thus they are aware of the issues and its solution. Therefore, it’s the best option to get your issue resolved. The service is available all round the clock, 24*7 to help the customers.
    quicken error cc-555
    Quicken Error CC-903
    quicken error ol-294-a
    Quicken Error Cc-592

    ResponderEliminar
  14. We are a certified, reliable, and self-governing third party Quicken support company, which is providing the best Quicken support services for our valued Quicken customers. While installing QuickBooks on your desktop system, you may get interrupted because of some unexpected problems. To rectify this error, you must install QuickBooks install diagnostic tool in the proper ways. If you don’t have experience to install this tool, you can take full guidance from trained QuickBooks professionals. Our QuickBooks experts can complete this installation procedure successfully, therefore you can enjoy this tool in the proper ways.
    quickbooks error 80029c4a
    QuickBooks Script Error
    QuickBooks file doctor
    QuickBooks payroll support

    ResponderEliminar
  15. I now had a stockpile of replies for the most "popular" wrong answers. Also, the history of wrong answers showed where students often were confused. I decided to use these as fodder for a series of multiple-choice questions (MCQs) and automate it! I discovered javascript. 360DIgiTMG data science institute in hyderabad

    ResponderEliminar
  16. Thanks for the Information.Interesting stuff to read.Great Article.
    I enjoyed reading your post, very nice share.
    Data Science Course Training in Hyderabad

    ResponderEliminar
  17. Publication: Get your research published in top-ranked journal with guaranteed accuracy, error-free document for submission,
    through a fast and reliable process that give your 100% satisfaction for open access journals publication.

    ResponderEliminar
  18. Thank you for sharing such a useful post with us, it will useful for everybody, so keep it up that is decent work.data science training in Hyderabad

    ResponderEliminar